Delicious Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream You Can Make at Home

Strawberry shortcake ice cream always felt like something I’d have to hunt down at a roadside stand or pay way too much for in a fancy grocery store freezer. I mean—just trying to recreate that nostalgic flavor at home? Seemed like a headache, honestly. Plus, let’s not kid ourselves—those late-night cravings don’t wait for a summer festival. If you ever made deep-fried strawberry cheesecake wonton bites or even something wild like strawberry cheesecake nachos, then you know homemade fun is best. So, if you’re chasing that creamy-creamy strawberry shortcake ice cream magic in your very own kitchen… just stick around. Turns out, it’s way easier than people let on.

Reasons You Should Try This Recipe

Listen, I’m pretty passionate about this stuff. If someone brings up dessert—especially homemade strawberry shortcake ice cream—my ears perk up. Frankly, if I had a dollar for every time I said to a friend, “You just gotta try making this!” I’d have enough to buy… well, a lot of strawberries.

First, you control every bit of it. No odd preservatives or mystery gummy bits you find in store-bought stuff. Also, the strawberry flavor from fresh berries basically dances in your mouth. I know, dramatic, but it’s true. Plus, scooping into a batch you made yourself? There’s a weird little pride there.

And, you barely need fancy gear. If you’ve got a hand mixer and a cake pan, you’re golden. I’ve tried recipes where you need a deep freezer and five types of vanilla—skip all that. This recipe is doable and fun. Honestly, it wins in summer, but when has anyone ever regretted strawberry shortcake in, say, February?

Let me toss in a quick note: my picky nephew had three bowls once—and he “hates strawberries.” If that’s not proof, nothing is.

How to Make Homemade Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream

Okay, here’s where things get hands-on. You don’t have to stand at the stove for hours. Seriously, it takes maybe 30-ish minutes to get everything ready, then your freezer does the rest. You mash fresh strawberries (just bashing with a fork or potato masher works!) with a bit of sugar. Don’t skip that part, it brings out the flavor. Then you whip cream till soft peaks form (kinda like fluffy mountains, but less intimidating). Fold in sweetened condensed milk. Chunk in those strawberries. And now the kicker—crumble in some store-bought shortbread cookies, or go wild and bake your own if you’re feeling extra.

Mix it together—in a loaf pan, a glass dish, whatever fits. Freeze four hours (I mean, longer is better, but who really waits overnight?). Scoop and serve. And, you know, panic a little if it’s almost gone because everyone’s sneaking spoonfuls before dinner.

Wanna see the strawberry ripple? Just swirl the mashed berries in rather than stirring them all the way through. Gives you those magazine-worthy streaks.

“This recipe tasted *exactly* like my favorite ice cream shop from when I was a kid. I didn’t even need an ice cream maker! I’m making it again for the family reunion next month.” –Maggie J.

Save

Tips and Tricks to Making Homemade Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Bars

Sometimes, my first try ends up a bit…eh. Here’s what I wish I’d known, right up front.

Use cold cream for best whipping—stick it in the coldest part of the fridge ahead of time. If you don’t want your shortbread bits to get too soggy, toss them in at the absolute last minute before freezing. Got only frozen berries? It’s cool, just thaw and drain so you don’t get a watery mess.

Also, use a tin that has a lid, or cover tightly with foil or even shower caps in a pinch (not joking, I’ve done that, works fine).

It freezes faster if your freezer isn’t packed with pizza boxes. Just saying. A couple of hours will do the trick, but give it a bit more time if you want super-firm bars that slice cleanly.

If you accidentally eat half the pan warm and soft, I definitely won’t judge.

Save

Can I Use a Different Berry?

Heck yes, you can! Blueberries, raspberries, blackberries—they all play nice in this recipe. Sometimes I even mix a few together if my fridge is looking sad. You might adjust the sugar if your berry isn’t naturally very sweet. Blueberries, for example, can be a bit tart, but that’s part of the fun.

It’s a great way to use up fruit before it goes mushy (don’t lie, you’ve had those mystery berries lurking in the fridge, too). Add lemon zest for a kick. Or, if your taste buds lean classic, stick to just strawberries. That’s always a crowd pleaser.

Switch up the cookies, too, if shortbread isn’t your jam—try vanilla wafers or those golden sandwich cookies everyone loves. Endless combos.

How Do I Store Strawberry Shortcake Bars?

If there’s any left (big if), just pop the ice cream bars into an airtight container. I usually wrap mine up tight with plastic wrap and a second layer of foil, but that’s just me being neurotic. You can easily stack them with parchment in between if you like things tidy—or, be like my cousin and just stack ’em tall with your hands.

You’ll want to eat these within two weeks for best texture and flavor. After that, the cookies start to lose their crunch and, well, the freezer gives ’em freezer taste. Nobody wants that. If you’re prepping for a party, you can slice and wrap them ahead. Thaw about five minutes before serving—extra bonus if you drizzle on some strawberry sauce or fresh berries.

If you like fruity treats, you’ll probably get a kick out of strawberry-rhubarb crumble or even creamy rhubarb cream cheese bars while you’re at it.

Common Questions

Let’s Make Your Kitchen the Happiest Place on Earth

Alright, so here’s the deal. Whipping up homemade strawberry shortcake ice cream is one of those “I can’t believe I did this myself” moments. You get to pick the berries, smash the cookies, swirl it all together… and the end result can rival anything from the five-star “Homemade Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream” shops. Want more inspiration? I peeked at how folks over at Tried Van Leeuwen’s Strawberry Shortcake… : r/icecream raved about theirs, and honestly, theirs isn’t even fresher than what you’ll make at home. So, go for it. Grab those strawberries (or whatever berries feel lucky) and make your own magic—your kitchen, your rules.

Print