Deliciously Easy Pizza Casserole That’ll Become a Family Favorite

Pizza casserole nights, let me tell ya, have saved my sanity. We’ve all had those evenings. You open the fridge hoping for dinner to jump out at you, but it just… doesn’t. The kids are squealing for pizza, but you forgot to buy dough (again). That’s when this pizza casserole swoops in and just makes everything easier—almost too easy. No more delivery apps, no staring at a cold frozen pizza—just hearty flavors, a bubbly crust… and everyone’s happy.

Table of Contents

Save

How to Make Pizza Casserole

Honestly, if you can boil pasta, you’re already doing 80% of the work. For this recipe, grab some rotini or penne. Cook it up—don’t cook it to oblivion, you want it firm-ish. Then, dump that pasta in your biggest baking dish. Now comes the fun stuff—dump a jar of marinara sauce over it, toss in tons of pepperoni, a mess of shredded mozzarella, and, if you’re wild, a handful of cooked ground beef. Mix it all up, but don’t make it pretty.

Top it with even more cheese (I mean, it’s not “pizza” unless it’s swimming in cheese). Scatter more pepperoni on top—don’t be shy. Bake it at 375 F until it looks bubbly on the sides and brown in the corners. I swear the hardest part is letting it cool before you shovel it in.

One night, I was rushing—and burned my tongue. Worth it? Maybe. Okay, definitely.

“I never thought my picky eaters would clean their plates, but this was gone in a flash. Next time, I might just double the batch.” – Jenny, friend and official casserole tester

Save

Recipe Substitutions

You forgot something at the store (it’s me, I’m “you” in this scenario). Don’t sweat it. Don’t have mozzarella? Use cheddar, or whatever cheese isn’t ancient in the back of your fridge. No pepperoni? Sausage slices will do the trick, or skip the meat for a veggie version. Gluten-free pasta? Go for it—my cousin swears you can’t tell once it’s all sauced up. There aren’t a lot of rules here; that’s why pizza casserole rules, honestly.

Save

Recipe Additions and Modifications

If you’re feeling fancy, sneak in some extra flavor. I’ve thrown in black olives, bell peppers (they give a nice crunch), or even those tiny canned mushrooms people love or hate. My sister likes it spicier, so she’ll sprinkle in red chili flakes and a dash of Italian seasoning. Like your pizza sweet? Pineapple chunks—yep, I said it, and don’t come at me. The world’s your casserole. Basically, toss in any of your favorite pizza toppings and just wait for the compliments to roll in.

Pizza Casserole Serving Suggestions

Gotta keep it simple, right? Here’s what works in my house:

• Pair it with a green salad with a splash of ranch or Italian dressing.
• Serve with garlic bread (store-bought or a make-your-own situation).
• Add a few pickle spears—don’t ask me why, but it just works.

Kids usually just eat it out of the pan standing in the kitchen, honestly, but do what feels right for your crew.

Save

Storing Leftovers

So, you made too much pizza casserole. (Is there such a thing?) Anyway, just pop any leftovers in a tight-sealed container. Fridge, three days easy. Reheat in the microwave—give it a quick stir halfway, so you don’t get cold spots. If you’re freezing, portion it out first. That way you’re not hacking at an ice brick a week later. I sometimes like it cold for lunch. Is that weird? I hope not.

Common Questions

Pizza Night Upgrade Awaits

There you go—everything you need to know to rock pizza casserole tonight. You don’t need to be a five-star chef, or even a three-star chef, just a hungry human with a baking dish. Don’t be afraid to tweak it, play with toppings, make it your own. If you’re looking for more inspiration, check out this Pepperoni Pizza Casserole Recipe for a classic take or the Pizza Casserole Recipe – Tastes Better From Scratch for more pro tips. Go on—try it. Your new family favorite is waiting right in your oven.

Save

Print